Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle, Madison Mogen, and Kaylee Goncalves Idaho Student Murders Moscow, Idaho, United States Murder 217 episodes Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Catalina Foothills (Tucson suburb), Arizona, United States Kidnapping 122 episodes John O'Keefe John O'Keefe Case Canton, Massachusetts, United States Murder 103 episodes The Women of Gilgo Beach Gilgo Beach Murders Gilgo Beach (Long Island), New York, United States Murder 89 episodes Ana Walshe Brian Walshe Case Cohasset, Massachusetts, United States Murder 33 episodes Spencer and Monique Tepe Tepe Murders Columbus (Weinland Park), Ohio, United States Murder 29 episodes Madeline Soto Kissimmee, Florida, United States Murder 22 episodes Asha Degree Shelby, North Carolina, United States Disappearance 19 episodes Jessica Gaudie, Celina Bridge, and Sabrina Ann Glassop Sunshine Coast Disappearances Nambour / Kenilworth (Sunshine Coast hinterland), Queensland, Australia Murder 17 episodes Aliza Sherman Aliza Sherman Case Cleveland, Ohio, United States Murder 9 episodes Tupac Shakur Las Vegas, Nevada, United States Murder 9 episodes Michael Fosler Aaron Spencer Case Lonoke County, Arkansas, United States Murder 8 episodes Travis Decker Manhunt Washington State (possibly fled to Canada), Washington, United States Murder 7 episodes Mercedes Vega Mercedes Vega Murder Tempe / Tonopah, Arizona, United States Murder 6 episodes Kada Scott Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States Disappearance 5 episodes Ashley Flynn Tipp City Murder Tipp City, Ohio, United States Murder 5 episodes Amy Hooper Amy Hooper Case Columbus (Lincoln Village), Ohio, United States Murder 2 episodes Waukesha Welfare Check Murders Waukesha, Wisconsin, United States Murder 2 episodes