Voices for the Victims
Report for jury duty each week with Brandi Churchwell. As the host of 13th Juror, Brandi walks you through the heart of a case, not just the crime, but the trial. The prosecution’s strategy. The defense’s counterargument. The testimony the jury heard, and at times, the evidence they didn’t hear.
122 most recent episodes
Visit website →Easter Sunday, 1991. Bill Little is found shot behind the counter of a Bloomington gas station, and the case stalls without physical evidence. Years later, prosecutors build their case against Jamie Snow through eyewitness accounts, statements, and r
Aileen Wuornos takes the stand and delivers a chilling account that could change everything the jury thought they knew. As the defense challenges the prosecution’s narrative, disturbing allegations and emotional confessions blur the line between pred
Seven men are dead, their bodies scattered along Florida’s highways, and one woman stands at the center of it all. The prosecution paints Aileen Wuornos not as a victim but as a predator driven by greed and control. As their case unfolds, the line be
What happens when the verdict is read but the story is far from over? In this episode, we go beyond the jury box to uncover the evidence the jury never saw, the lawsuits that followed, and the revelations that continue to cast doubt on what really ha
Just when the case seems clear, Casey Anthony's defense turns everything upside down with a version of events no one saw coming. Shocking claims, fractured family dynamics, and disputed evidence collide to cast doubt on what really happened. As the n
Step inside the prosecution’s case against Casey Anthony. Examine the timeline, forensic evidence, and her web of lies presented to the jury. From the mysterious disappearance of her daughter Caylee, to chilling discoveries made close to the Anthony
Robert Atrops called police repeatedly the night his wife disappeared. Prosecutors called his actions suspicious, but the defense says they were simply the moves of a worried husband. Add in evolving memories, flawed forensic interpretation, and a se
When 30-year-old Deborah Atrops was found strangled in the trunk of her car in 1988, suspicion quickly turned to her estranged husband, but the case went cold for more than three decades. Now, with new forensic soil analysis, advanced DNA testing, an
From explosive allegations to a headline-making verdict, now Amber Heard takes the stand and tells her story. One of power, fear, and what she says her life was like behind closed doors.
What happens when a marriage implodes under the glare of worldwide fame and the fallout becomes a $50 million defamation battle? Hear Johnny Depp’s version of events, from volatile fights to the op-ed he claims ended his career.
The prosecution called it a clear case of guilt. The defense called it a rush to judgment. Revisit the Scott Peterson trial through the defense’s lens, unpacking disputed evidence, alternative theories, and developments still unfolding years later.
When Laci Peterson vanished on Christmas Eve 2002, a missing-person search quickly turned into one of the most infamous murder cases in modern history. Prosecutors laid out a case built on lies, timelines, and a secret life they say reveals motive an
The verdict may be final, but the unanswered questions are not. Brandi and Bob Motta (Defense Diaries) revisit the Delphi case through the lens of what jurors were barred from hearing, especially the third-party culprit evidence and the Odinism defen
Was Richard Allen really the man on the bridge, or did investigators lock onto a suspect while overlooking evidence that pointed elsewhere? In this episode, the defense exposes investigative failures, conflicting eyewitness accounts, and digital evid
A cellphone video, a single unspent bullet, and a man who admits he was there. The prosecution says these pieces finally reveal the truth behind one of America’s most haunting unsolved murders. But do they prove guilt or just proximity? Dive into the
Trials don’t always tell the whole story. In this bonus episode, we step outside the jury box with Travis Rudolph’s defense team to uncover hidden evidence, questionable police work, and bombshell details that never made it into court.
A football star fighting for redemption suddenly finds himself fighting for his life. The defense claims this wasn’t vengeance—it was survival. Hear their version of events that could make you question everything you thought you knew.
One night, four unarmed men walked away from a fight—until Travis Rudolph opened fire. The prosecution’s case rests on one question: where does self-defense end and murder begin?
The defense tears into the state’s case against Leo Schofield, exposing timeline gaps, shaky eyewitness testimony, and a glaring forensic twist: fingerprints in Michelle’s Mazda that aren't Leo's. From a guilty verdict to a long fight for freedom and
A neighbor’s sleepless night, a steam cleaner, and a father who says God led him to the body... Prosecutors say Leo Schofield’s rage boiled over, and they have the witnesses and evidence to prove it. Step into the jury box as the State lays out its c
Decades after five Winston-Salem 5 were convicted of murdering Nathaniel Jones, new DNA testing, expert testimony, and a key witness’s recantation blow the case wide open. Follow the fight beyond the courtroom—through the Innocence Inquiry, a 2025 ev
Five teens, six “confessions,” and a murder that shook Winston-Salem—what happens when the loudest evidence is fear? In this defense-side deep dive, we unpack hours of unrecorded interrogations, shifting stories, and forensic dead ends that challenge
The brutal murder of Chris Paul's grandfather, Nathaniel Jones, shocked the town of Winston-Salem. Prosecutors say five teens set out for “easy money,” leaving a trail of confessions, a star witness, and a shoeprint on a Lincoln’s hood. Step inside t
As the defense takes center stage, the Lizzie Borden trial twists into a battle of logic versus legend. Every piece of evidence is reexamined, every assumption dismantled. Was Lizzie a victim of circumstance—or the most misunderstood suspect in Ameri
The evidence seemed damning: a locked house, a vanished note, and a hatchet in the cellar. But could the prosecution really prove Lizzie Borden guilty beyond doubt? Step into the courtroom where America’s most notorious murder trial unfolded.
The verdict was only half the story. Uncover the evidence jurors never saw—sealed wiretaps, secret hearings, and the family fractures that shattered the Adelsons long before the trial began.
A mother’s meddling or a mastermind’s plot? In part two of Florida v. Donna Adelson, the defense paints her not as a killer but as an overbearing grandmother caught in a storm of extortion, suspicion, and family betrayal. Their version of events asks
A Harvard-trained law professor executed in his driveway. A bitter custody battle turned deadly. In part one of Florida v. Donna Adelson, prosecutors argue this doting grandmother wasn’t just meddling—she was the mastermind behind a murder-for-hire p
Week 9—After 36 days, the second trial of Karen Read has come to an end, but what did the jury ultimately decide?
Week 8—Cranky Hanky returns with a vengeance against Dr. Rentschler, and the defense rests their case!
Week 7: The defense begins their case, and fireworks erupt in the courtroom as one attorney demands a mistrial...
Week 6: The prosecution wraps up their case with Dr. Welcher, and I go down a Welcher rabbit hole...
Week 5: DNA Bombshell on the hair; Glass comparisons; a brain surgeon, and the most controversial digital analyst we've ever seen. Plus, juror drama, and a judge's order on three Buffer Zone petitioners.
Go to shopremi.com/BRANDI and use code BRAND
Week 4: The jury is finally hearing technical testimony- including state crime lab analysts, DNA, and the medical examiner. But a last minute expert report change threatens to disrupt the defense's entire strategy, and a questionable ruling by Judge
Week 3 (Part 2): The prosecution has said they aren't calling Former Trooper Michael Proctor to the stand, which means questioning about the investigation, falls to his former parter on the case (and superior), Sgt Yuri Bukhenik. Bukhenik spends thre
Week 3 (Part 1): The jury gets their first peak inside the investigation from Canton PD, and the SERT team search. Witnesses from 34 Fairview are called, but not the ones everyone expected. Digital data is discussed, and Brennan's approach reveals it
Week 2 (Part 2): Jen. Jen. Jen.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and the 2nd trial is just beginning. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in Massachusetts history
Week 2 (Part 1): The ARCCA Voir Dire that had Hank Brennan YELLING at a witness; An update on the hand painted rock at the jury view; Prosecution expert Ian Whiffin returns, and gives some new info; And Aidan Kearney, aka Turtleboy is back in court-
Trial Week One: Openings lay out the theories of each side; Mrs O'Keefe takes the stand for the first time; First responders testify, and Kerry Roberts is called out for giving false information to the grand jury about one of the most contested piece
The final motions hearing, plus jury updates.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and the 2nd trial is just beginning. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in Massach
Jury Selection, The Canton Police Audit Results and Questions, Civil Case Update, & Trial Start Date
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to d
Jury selection has officially started in Karen Read's second trial, and all the final arguments are heard before opening statements get underway.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year veter
Tensions remain high in the courtroom for the hearing on March 20th, causing Judge Cannone to step in and ask for personal attacks to stop. Karen's interviews are being used against her by the prosecution, the defense wants to bring in a retired FBI
With the trial approaching, a flurry of last minute motions from both sides start to give us an idea of how different this trial will be. Plus, tensions are rising in the courtroom, causing heated exchanges between attorneys. And, the trial board has
The hearing that everyone was talking about- the defense's Motion to Dismiss for Governmental Misconduct. This one gets spicy. The judge is mad, the defense is mad, and Brennan is Brennan.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history,
"A Lie Unchecked Becomes the Truth." In this episode, we are checking- calling out this HUGE misrepresentations from the Commonwealth to the judge. Also, a shocking decision from the judge, and the end of the federal investigation.
Back in Court to Address the Judge's "Grave Concerns"; Plus the NEW Motion to Dismiss Based on Government Misconduct & Jury Tamering! BIG Episode..
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year vet
Juror Interview, Karen Read Interview, & The Hearing that Caused Judge Cannone to Start Shaking, Cancel the Rest of the Day, and Mention "Grave Concerns"
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 ye
A TON of new filings heading into the 2nd trial- Brennan wants the ARCCA experts out, the defense is STILL getting new clips of sally port video, and Proctor's texts make it back into court filings. Again.
Part 7: The Defense
The case against Letecia has been presented, and now it's time for the jury to hear the defense. There are two doctors who testify, including one high profile doctor who causes a HUGE stir in this case. The jury will watch clips o
The prosecution is wanting to exclude another defense witness, and the hearing gets spicy. Plus, Judge Cannone reverses a previous ruling, and new information comes out about video footage from Canton Police Department, which raises some MAJOR questi
Part 3: Ripping the Wings off an Angel
After Murdock takes the stand to tell his story, he is then opened up to a fiery cross examination. We hear from Lisa's family and Sanda, and also from Murdock's older sister. Then, Murdock takes the stand AGAIN
Bonus Episode: The prosecutors hold nothing back during cross examination of David Marshall Murdock. Plus, he takes the stand AGAIN, and also addresses Sanda, and Lisa's family directly.
Best friends Lisa Bunce and Sanda Andrews were sitting on the
The Trial Begins: After more than 5 years, the death penalty trial of David Murdock begins in Polk County, Florida. The prosecution lays out the case, piece by piece. Sanda Andrews gives an emotional testimony, and the jury hears from David's ex-girl
Bonus Episode: Listen to the full testimony of David Murdock, directly from the transcripts. His story is NOT what I was expecting.
Best friends Lisa Bunce and Sanda Andrews were sitting on the front porch of Sanda's Florida home after a night out when 60 year old David Murdock pulled up and opened fire. Murdock shot Sanda once in the face, and shot Lisa a total of three times. H
The fiery Daubert Hearing- Will Dr Marie Russell's testimony be allowed in again? Plus- Is the 2:27 am search actually hurting the defense? And the Commonwealth now wants Richard Greene and the ARCCA experts excluded. That's four out of six of the de
In May of 2016, a man is gunned down in the street walking home from a concert in the park. Louisville rapper Brice Rhodes shoots the man thinking there is a bounty on his head, but doesn't realize he has the wrong guy. Teen brothers Larry and Mauric
In May of 2016, a man is gunned down in the street walking home from a concert in the park. Louisville rapper Brice Rhodes shoots the man thinking there is a bounty on his head, but doesn't realize he has the wrong guy. Teen brothers Larry and Mauric
The Black Swan Finale: Allegations of Juror Misconduct- What did the jurors have to say? Defense Alleges Prosecutorial Misconduct & Wants a New Trial. Plus, The Sentencing- Eva finally gets to address Ashley.
Motions Hearing- Prosecution Wants Phone Records for Karen's Parents, and All Media Notes and Interviews
This episode is sponsored by/brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/JUROR and get on your way to being your b
Three young men found executed at the gates of a remote quarry in Wisconsin. Police had no suspects and no leads, until a woman walks into the Sheriff's office and says not only does she have information, but she drove the victims there and witnessed
Motions Filed for the New Trial; Vanity Fair Article Makes Some Waves; SJC & Civil Case Updates
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in
Get 15% off OneSkin with the code BRANDI at https://www.oneskin.co/ #oneskinpod
This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/juror and get on your way to being your best self.
Part 3 of the Bederow Bo
The Revengers- The Background to Understanding the Bederow Letters: Did MSP, the DA, and Three Angry Enemies Conspire Against Aidan Kearney? (part 2 of the Bederow Bombs)
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is fina
SJC Appeal Updates; More Fallout & People Leaving; Who is Mark Bederow; The Charges Against Aidan Kearney, aka Turtleboy (part 1 of the Bederow Bombs).
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year
This show is sponsored by Magic Mind. You have a limited offer you can use now that gets you up to 48% off your first subscription or 20% off one-time purchases with code JUROR20 at checkout. You can claim it at: https://www.magicmind.com/juror20
Th
Laurie Shaver is accused of fatally shooting her husband Michael Shaver in November 2015, burying him in the backyard under a fire pit, and then impersonating him in texts and Facebook messages to make people think he was still alive. Laurie was arre
This show is sponsored by Magic Mind. You have a limited offer you can use now that gets you up to 48% off your first subscription or 20% off one-time purchases with code JUROR20 at checkout. You can claim it at: https://www.magicmind.com/juror20
T
The Black Swan Murder Trial (Part 3)
Retired Navy pilot Doug Benefield lost his wife from heart complications in December of 2015, when their daughter Eva was only 14 years old.
Nine months later, Doug meets Ashley Byers at a political fundraiser.
Laurie Shaver is accused of fatally shooting her husband Michael Shaver in November 2015, burying him in the backyard under a fire pit, and then impersonating him in texts and Facebook messages to make people think he was still alive. Laurie was arre
The O'Keefe's Civil Suit Against Karen, Waterfall, & CF McCarthy's; Judge Cannone's Decision on the Motion to Dismiss; & Matthew Farwell Arrested & Charged with Sandra Birchmore's Murder
The Black Swan Murder Trial (Part 2): The Split- Poisoned
Retired Navy pilot Doug Benefield lost his wife from heart complications in December of 2015, when their daughter Eva was only 14 years old.
Nine months later, Doug meets Ashley Byers at a p
The Hearing for the Motion to Dismiss- Marty Weinberg Joins the Defense
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest bliz
The Black Swan Murder Trial (Part 1): The Start of The Fairytale
Retired Navy pilot Doug Benefield lost his wife from heart complications in December of 2015, when their daughter Eva was only 14 years old.
Nine months later, Doug meets Ashley Byers
Toyota Techstream Expert Discusses the Case Facts; Canton Residents Voice Their Anger at Select Board Meetings; Sandra Burchmore Information; Chris Albert's Past
This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online
therapy a try at betterhelp.com/j
Post Trial Drama- Jurors Reach Out, Proctor Suspended, More IA Investigations, & Fighting Among the Sides
This episode is brought to you by Magic Mind- You have a limited offer you can use now, that gets you up to 48% off your first subscription or
The End Of Trial- Closing Arguments, Deliberations, And Verdict
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in
This episode is brought to you by Factor! Enjoy effortless meals for your lifestyle, and head to factormeals.com/juror50 for half off your first box, plus 20% off your next month.
Reconstructionists- Trooper Paul v ARCCA (Part 2)
It's one of the mo
Reconstructionists- Trooper Paul v ARCCA (Part 1)
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is finally over. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in Massachusetts
Trial Experts- Apple Health Data vs Waze Location Data and the Medical Examiners Weigh in on Cause of Injuries
This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/juror and get on your way to being your best self.
Episode 20- The Final Witnesses (part 1)
This is the first of two parts, putting together the final witness
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is underway. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in Massachusetts history. Prosecution has charged his girlfriend, 42 ye
This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/juror and get on your way to being your best self.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is underway. A 16 year veteran of the
This episode is all about Higgins, and there's a lot.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is underway. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in Massachuset
This week we cover the testimony of Matt and Jen McCabe, including some heated exchanges in the cross examinations. Jen McCabe details to the jury the harassment she has faced, Kerry Roberts testifies about the morning she found John O'Keefe in the s
Rounding out the last of the witness testimony from Waterfall and 34 Fairview. Colin Albert takes the stand and is subject to a fiery cross. Multiple witnesses bring up harassment they've faced, and the dog DNA expert testifies.
It's one of the most
Trial is moving along, and there's drama both inside and outside of the courthouse. In this episode we go over the testimony of homeowners Brian and Nicole Albert, as well as the drama and legal action being taken outside the courthouse in the media
Trial is underway! In this episode we go through the investigation and the endless problems with it, as well as the witnesses from CF McCarthy's and Waterfall.
First week of trial is complete, and in this episode we hear testimony from the victim's brother and his wife, and we will also piece together the scene according to the first responders.
The Trial Begins.
We are off to a big start in the explosive opening statements.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and trial is underway. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the bigge
This week we go over the explosive final pre-trial hearing. Frustrated attorneys, new information and allegations, and Karen's voice on bodycam video. We will go through the motions filed and why they're important. There's also an update on motions f
Jury selection is finally underway, and we are days away from opening statements. In this episode, I talk to Dr. Kenny Kinsey about the injuries Office John O'Keefe sustained and how they line up to both theories. I also talk about the OTHER alleged
This week we dive into the evidence against Karen Read- The DNA, the hair we've heard so much about in court proceedings, Chloe the German Shepherd, John's clothing, and more.
It's one of the most polarizing cases in true crime history, and we have
This week we wrap up the data timeline and take a look at what theories we are able to eliminate based on what we've learned so far.
Technology & Data Footprint - Part Two
Mark Tinsley is a South Carolina attorney known for representing the family of Mallory Beach, calling out Alex Murdaugh, and the infamous cross examination with Phil Barber that lead to some of the most replayed moments of the entire Murdaugh trial.
Technology and Data Footprint
The Fight For Evidence
Anyone who has spent any time watching true crime can tell you technology is one of the primary ways law enforcement agencies are able to solve crimes. Location data, surveillance videos, call records, even health apps are all
The Searches
It's literally the Low Country Dream Team, all together in one place!! Journalist Mandy Matney who exposed Murdaugh corruption; Dr Kenny Kinsey, who put all the evidence together to figure out what happened and how; and Mandy Powers Norrell, who know
Conflicting Statements
Introduction To The Case
Dr. Amie Harwick was stunningly beautiful and incredibly smart, gaining her notoriety in Hollywood that lead to some high profile relationships, including an engagement to Drew Carey. One relationship, with ex Gareth Pursehouse, ended with her gettin
13 year old Cristina Pangalagan was left in a hot car in August in Colleton South Carolina for more than five hours, resulting in her death. Her mom, Rita, had been named 2014 Teacher of the Year in Walterboro’s Black Street Early Education Center. R
13 year old Cristina Pangalagan was left in a hot car in August in Colleton South Carolina for more than five hours, resulting in her death. Her mom, Rita, had been named 2014 Teacher of the Year in Walterboro’s Black Street Early Education Center. R
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
We begin with an interview with Eric Carter-Landin to discuss his show, his success, and the case involving his brother Jacob Landin.
We want to shed light on this case as it has been a gross miscarriage of (or lackthereof) justice.
Join me for thi
13th Juror welcomes Criminal Defense Attorneys Marc Shiner & Heidi Perlet!
Marc Shiner
Over the course of his career, Mr. Shiner has achieved notable success. As a former major crimes prosecutor for the State Attorney’s Office, he has had 250 jury a
13th Juror welcomes former major crimes prosecutor turned criminal defense attorney- Marc Shiner!
Mr. Shiner spent almost 13 years working at the State Attorney's Office before dedicating his career to helping people accused of crimes. He represente
Thomas Randolph has had 6 wives. Four of them are dead, three by suspicious circumstances. Join in as we dig into this stranger-than-life trial and all the details.
Please Note: All content including the presentation thereof on this channel is the p
Part 6: The Trial
It's finally time for the state to present its case against Letecia- but changing her plea from "Not Guilty" to "Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity", changes EVERYTHING. The prosecution no longer has to prove Letecia murdered Gannon,
Part 5: Trapped
It's been 3 weeks since Gannon was last seen alive, and with a mountain of evidence piling up against Letecia, she's feeling more trapped than ever. In desperation, she offers to take a polygraph test for Al, and tries to enlist the h
Part 4: The Calls
Letecia knows that all eyes- and suspicion- are aimed at her. Al and the police are desperate to find Gannon, and Letecia is desperate to avoid being the only suspect. Her story about Eguardo the carpet guy didn't pan out, so Leteci
Part 3: Suspect
Letecia's bizarre behavior starts to raise some eyebrows in the community, with the police, and with Al. A search of the Stauch home and Gannon's room paints a gruesome picture, and when police get the data back from Letecia's phone,
Part 2: The Search
Gannon's disappearance ignites massive search efforts all over the Colorado Springs community. As Al Stauch arrives back to CO to find his son, he's met with bizarre behavior from Letecia, raising red flags that cause him to questi
Part 1: Missing
In January of 2020 11-year-old Gannon Stauch is reported missing by his stepmother Letecia in Colorado Springs, CO, sparking a massive search effort involving volunteers, as well as multiple law enforcement agencies. As the community